Let's Talk

Home  >  About

Zero sales. Zero pressure.

PEO direct sales reps are compensated to do one thing: Sell you their solution.

PairPEO's services are designed to take all of the sales fluff out of the conversation and focus on the real impact PEOs can have on your employees and bottom line. If the results from our RFP don't hit the mark, we won't waste your time.

We’ll tell you what you need to hear.

Overview

What is
PairPEO?

Pair PEO is a broker that helps companies save time and money by finding a PEO that aligns with their needs and budget.

  • Created by potrace 1.16, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2019 We believe in doing what’s right for our clients, nothing less.
  • Created by potrace 1.16, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2019 We’ll educate you on how a PEO works and what you’ll really get out of the relationship.
  • Created by potrace 1.16, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2019 We'll help you look at all of your options with an insider's knowledge and expertise. And as your partner, our only job is to advise you on your next best move. So, if we see that the best option isn’t to switch right now, but just to stay put, you can trust us to tell you.
How It Works

We’ll tell you what you need to hear.

We believe in doing what’s right for our clients, nothing less.

We’ll educate you on how a PEO works and what you’ll really get out of the relationship.
We’ll help you look at the options with an insider’s knowledge and expertise. And as your partner, our only job is to advise you on your next best move. So, if we see that the best option isn’t to switch right now, but just to stay put, you can trust us to tell you.

Our People

Jeffrey Wanner

President & Founder

Broc Buxton

VP of Client Success

Jayne Overturf

Advisor

About the CEO

Jeff Wanner, CEO and President

Jeff Wanner, the driving force behind PairPEO, brings a wealth of experience and passion to the professional employer organization (PEO) industry. Jeff began his PEO career at Insperity, where he quickly recognized that there was a more effective way to assist clients in finding the perfect PEO match for their unique needs. This insight inspired him to establish PairPEO in March 2019, with a mission to revolutionize the way businesses connect with PEO services.

Jeff’s vision for PairPEO is rooted in his commitment to providing personalized and strategic collaborations with clients.

“PEOs are not a one-size-fits-all solution and may not be suitable for every business. Our goal is to help business owners make informed decisions to prevent choices that could negatively impact their business and employees.”

– Jeff Wanner, CEO of PairPEO

Outside of his professional endeavors, Jeff is a devoted family man who cherishes the time spent with his growing family. He is also an avid Cleveland sports fan, passionately supporting his hometown teams. Jeff’s dedication to both his family and his clients exemplifies the values that drive PairPEO’s success.

Hear from our clients.

Our team

Matt Butler, Chief Revenue Officer

Matt Butler is the CRO at PairPEO, a national PEO broker and HR advisory firm. Matt has nearly two decades of experience working with PEOs, where he has helped hundreds of small, medium, and middle-market businesses simplify HR, manage risk, and lower HR operational costs while unlocking growth opportunities and enhancing profitability.

As a serial entrepreneur and active investor, Matt is deeply involved in the capital markets and understands how HR & PEOs can build enterprise value for businesses, investors, and shareholders while scaling operations and optimizing people strategies.

Most importantly, Matt is a family man, a devoted husband, and a proud father of three.

Broc Buxton, Vice President of Operations

Broc thrives on solving complex challenges — from helping clients navigate their PEO medical renewals to streamlining internal processes for his team. He takes pride in bringing clarity to complicated issues and finds the greatest reward in the relief business owners feel when a tough problem is handled.

His passion for connecting people and creating meaningful solutions extends beyond client work. Broc is driven to understand what matters most to the businesses and individuals he serves and is committed to supporting their success — both professionally and personally.

When he’s not at PairPEO, Broc is immersed in sports and staying active. A diehard Cleveland sports fan, he follows the Guardians, Cavaliers, and never misses a Browns game. He enjoys sand volleyball, golf, bowling, and pickleball, and loves traveling with his wife and spoiling their adopted French Bulldog, Luigi.

Ready to save time and money?

Get Started